Public-Private Investment Partnerships: Efficiency Estimation Methods
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17059/2016-2-23Keywords:
public-private partnership, PPP, public sector, external economic effects, multiplier effect, “value for money” analysis, cost-effectiveness analysis, balance model of regional economy, social accounting matrix, SAMAbstract
The article focuses on assessing the effectiveness of investment projects implemented on the principles of public-private partnership (PPP). This article puts forward the hypothesis that the inclusion of multiplicative economic effects will increase the attractiveness of public-private partnership projects, which in turn will contribute to the more efficient use of budgetary resources. The author proposed a methodological approach and methods of evaluating the economic efficiency of PPP projects. The authors technique is based upon the synthesis of approaches to evaluation of the project implemented in the private and public sector and in contrast to the existing methods allows taking into account the indirect (multiplicative) effect arising during the implementation of project. In the article, to estimate the multiplier effect, the model of regional economy - social accounting matrix (SAM) was developed. The matrix is based on the data of the Sverdlovsk region for 2013. In the article, the genesis of the balance models of economic systems is presented. The evolution of balance models in the Russian (Soviet) and foreign sources from their emergence up to now are observed. It is shown that SAM is widely used in the world for a wide range of applications, primarily to assess the impact on the regional economy of various exogenous factors. In order to clarify the estimates of multiplicative effects, the disaggregation of the account of the “industry” of the matrix of social accounts was carried out in accordance with the All-Russian Classifier of Types of Economic Activities (OKVED). This step allows to consider the particular characteristics of the industry of the estimated investment project. The method was tested on the example of evaluating the effectiveness of the construction of a toll road in the Sverdlovsk region. It is proved that due to the multiplier effect, the more capital-intensive version of the project may be more beneficial in terms of future tax revenue. The proposed method can be used by the state and municipal authorities in the evaluation and substantiation of projects on a public-private partnership.References
Trynov, A. V. (2014). Predposylki vozniknoveniya i printsipy realizatsii proektov gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva v Rossii [Predictors and principles of public-private partnership in Russia]. Jurnal ekonomicheskoy teorii [Journal of economic theory], 4, 192–200.
Sidorova, E. N. & Tatarkin, D. A. (2011). Gosudarstvenno-chastnoye partnerstvo: rol, problem, vozmozhnosti [Public-private partnership: role, problems, opportunities]. Ekaterinburg: Institute of Economics of UB RAS Publ., 228.
Bierman, H. & Smidt, S. (2006). Ekonomicheskiy analiz investitsionnykh proektov [Economic analysis of investment projects]. Moscow: IUNITI Publ., 630.
Vilensky, P. L., Livshits, V. N. & Smolyak, S. L. (2002). Otsenka effektivnosti investitsionnykh proektov: teoriya i praktika [Evaluating the effectiveness of investment projects. Theory and practice]. Moscow: Delo Publ., 888.
Issledovanie mnogoregionalnykh ekonomicheskich system. Opyt primeneniya optimizatsionnykh mezhregionalnykh mezhotraslevykh sistem [Research of multiregional economic systems: experience of the application of optimizing multiregional intersectoral systems]. Novosibirsk: IEIE SB RAS Publ., 250.
Melentiev, B. V., Ershov, B. V. & Alimpieva, A. A. (2010). Metodicheskie rekomendatsii postroeniya mnogoregionalnogo mezhotraslevogo finansovogo balansa «platezhi-dokhody» [Guidelines of the developing of the interregional cross-sectoral financial balance «payments-income»]. Novosibirsk: IEIE SB RAS Publ.,144.
Tatarkin, D. A., Sidorova, E. N. & Trynov, A. V. (2015). Teoriya postroeniya i perspektivy ispolzovaniya balansovoy modeli finansovikh potokov [Balance model of the financial flows: theory of construction and prospects of use]. Zhurnal ekomicheskoy teorii [Journal of economic theory], 3, 62–74.
Pyatt, G. & Round, J. I. (1979). Accounting and Fixed Price Multipliers in a Social Accounting Matrix Framework. The Economic Journal, 89(356), 850–873.
Defourny, J. & Thorbecke, E. (1984). Structural Path Analysis and Multiplier Decomposition within a Social Accounting Matrix Framework. The Economic Journal, 94(373), 111–136.
Khan, H. & Thorbecke, E. (1989). Macroeconomic Effects of Technology Choice. Multiplier and Structural Path Analysis Within a SAM Framework. Journal of Policy Modeling, 11(1), 131–156.
Scandizzo, P. L. & Ferrarese, C. (2015). Social Accounting Matrix: A New Estimation Methodology. Journal of Policy Modeling, 37(1), 14–34.
Pieters, J. (2010). Growth and Inequality in India: Analysis of an Extended Social Accounting Matrix. World Development, 38(3), 270–281.
Kim, M-K., Zhu, E., Harris, T. R. & Alevy, J. E. (2012) An LP-SAM Approach for Examining Regional Economic Impacts: An Application to Wildfire Disasters in Southeast Oregon. The Review of Regional Studies, 42, 207–221.
Chang, S. K. (2014). Estimating Effects of Exogenous Output Changes: An Application of Multi-Regional Social Accounting Matrix (MRSAM) Method to Natural Resource Management. Regional Science Policy and Practice, 6(2), 179–194.
Santos, S. (2014). The Social Accounting Matrix and The Socio-Demographic Matrix-Based Approaches For Studying The Socioeconomics Of Ageing. Theoretical and Practical Research in Economic Fields, 5(9), 63–72.
Roland-Holst, D. W., & Ferran, S. (1995). Modeling Prices in a SAM Structure. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 77(2), 361–371.
Ali Akkmelik, K. (2011). Potential Impacts of Electricity Price Changes on Price Formation in the Economy: A Social Accounting Matrix Price Modeling Analysis for Turkey. Energy Policy, 39(2), 854–864.
Llop, M. (2012). The Role of Saving and Investment in a SAM Price Model. The Annals of Regional Science, 8(48), 339–357.
Go, D. S., Lofgren, H., Ramos, F. M. & Robinson, S. (2016, January). Estimating Parameters and Structural Change in CGE Models Using a Bayesian Cross-Entropy Estimation Approach. Economic Modelling, 52, Pt. B, 790–811.
Belousov, A. R. & Abramova, E. A. (1999). Eksperimentalnaya razrabotka integrirovannykh matrits finansovykh potokov [Experimental development of integrated matrix of financial flows]. Voprosy statistiki [Questions of statistics], 7, 11–24.
Mikheeva, N. N. (2011). Matritsy sotsialnykh shchetov: napravleniya issledovaniya i ogranicheniya ispolzovaniya [Social accounting matrix: research directions and limitations of use]. EKO [ECO], 6, 103–118.
Dondokov, Z. B-D. (2000). Multiplikatsionnyye effekty v ekonomike: metodologiya i metodika [Multiplicative effects in the economy: methodology and technique: doctoral published summery]. Irkutsk, 234.
Vlasyuk, L. I., Zakharchenko, N. G. & Kalashnikov, V. D. (2012). Issledovanie regionalnykh makroekonomicheskikh proportsiy i multiplikativnykh effektov: Habarovskiy kray [The study of regional macroeconomic proportions and multiplicative effects: on the example of the Khabarovsk region]. Prostranstvennaya ekonomika [Spatial economics], 1, 44–66.
Tatarkin, D. A., Sidorova, E. N. & Trynov, A. V. (2015). Upravlenie finansovymi potokami na osnove otsenki regionalnykh multiplikativnykh effektov [Management of financial flows based on the evaluation of the regional multiplicative effects]. Ekaterinburg: Institute of Economics of UB RAS Publ., 156.
Soldatova, S. E., Voloshenko, K. Y & Ogneva, N. F. (2015). Matrichnoye predstavlenie pokazateley sistemy regionalnkyh shchetov Kaliningradskoy oblasti: eksperimentalnaya razrabotka i perspektivy modelirovaniya [Matrix representation of the Kaliningrad region’s accounts system: experimental development and modelling prospects]. Baltiysky region [Baltic Region], 3, 126–137.
Naumov, I. V. (2013). Finansovaya ustoychivost territotiy. Osnovnyye pokzateli i indjcatory otsenki [Financial stability of the territories]. Ekonomika. Nalogi. Pravo. [Economics. Tax. Law], 6, 63–71.
Tatarkin, D. A., Sidorova, E. N. & Trynov A. V. (2015). Optimizatsiya upravleniya finansovymi potokami na osnove otsenki regionalnykh multiplikativnykh effektov [Optimization of financial flow management based on estimation of regional multiplicative effects]. Ekonomika regiona [Economy of region], 4, 323–335.
Animitsa, P. E. (2016). Modelirovanie vliyaniya domashnikh khozyaystv na sozdanie multiplikativnykh effektov v regione (na primere Sverdlovskoy Oblasti) [Modeling of households to create a multiplier effect in the region on the example of Sverdlovsk Region]. Upravlenets [Manager], 2, (In Press).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2016 Aleksandr Valeryevich Trynov
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
